Michael V said:
party_pants said:
Michael V said:I don’t understand why not adding extra high speed rail is economic vandalism. The amount of rail lines that already criss-cross the UK is mind-boggling.
It was supposed to be a transformative infrastructure project. The existing rail network was mostly laid out and constructed prior to 1900. It is slow and congested, with local and regional services all trying to use the same space. HS2 was going to be a new standalone track for high speed passenger trains. Planned speeds were initially around 360 km/h but this was later revised down to 320 km/h. Still this would cut journey times between major cities significantly and would make rail the go-to option for intercity travel, ahead of driving or flying. it would also free up capacity for better local services on the existing tracks. The route was chosen, the land was acquired (some of it by forced sale to the government), the environmental plans approved, and construction ready to start. Construction had started on Phase 1, from just outside London to Birmingham. Phase 2 was the branch extensions north to Manchester and one to Leeds, and connecting it to London Euston via new tunnels. The Phase 2 stuff got cancelled.
The route now runs only from the outskirts of London (Old Oak Common) to Birmingham. Without the full planned network it will likely never reach the passenger numbers to make it profitable. Nor will it become the default option for intercity passengers. Passengers from London will need to get their own way to Old Oak Common, which kind of defeats the purpose a bit of having a direct connection to the great cities of the north. It has been set up to become a financial burden on the taxpayer if it can’t generate enough revenue on its own services.
When I was there a few years back I found the rail network more than adequate. Train speeds were much faster than any I have experienced here. No way I would use a car for inter-city travel.
It is not hard to beat anything rail in Australia, but that’s not really the point. The point was that having committed to build the first phase and then cancelling the second phase, they’ll end up with a line that doesn’t go anywhere, and won’t ever run at a profit. It is a wasted opportunity, either build the whole thing or don’t build it at all. Building half of it and abandoning the rest (just so PM could sell his budget) is economic vandalism.