Date: 24/09/2026 18:58:00
From: ms spock
ID: 2433165
Subject: re: US/Israel/Iran War

Cymek said:


captain_spalding said:

Cymek said:

The USA don’t support war crimes if they are the instigators
A question though, is it a war crime to kill civilians if it prevents your weaponry from being destroyed
You’re in a gunship its coming under fire, you retaliate and it stops but a bunch of civies are killed in the process
That’s OK under rules of war ?

Yes.

Self-defence is an inherent right, but it is not absolute; soldiers must assess the risk and use only the minimum force necessary to neutralise the threat.

You’re NOT allowed to deliberately target civilians, but if the fire is coming from somewhere where there’s civilians, then that’s unfortunate, but you’re not expected to just take it and not respond.

This is where outfits like HAMAS and Hezbollah lie to their fighters, and the civilian population. They tell them that if they use civilians as shields, the ‘other side’ is not allowed to fire back.

Despite multitudinous examples that this is not true, they persist with the tactic.

Yeah it’s all quite morally bankrupt.
We aren’t allowed to say we support terrorists and for the most part they are despicable humans
However what our governments are loath to mention is we are barely any better.
I single out the USA as they have killed millions of civilians in wars
Its all justified and its not justifiable at all

There’s a NYT’s article that does a deep dive on this.

For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces
The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from
by Tal Schneider

Link

Reply Quote View full thread