Date: 28/09/2026 16:32:11
From: SCIENCE
ID: 2434411
Subject: re: Electric cars

roughbarked said:

dv said:

Spiny Norman said:

Michael V said:

SCIENCE said:

seems to be constantly bordering on disinformation there

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-28/how-to-maximise-ev-range-and-minimise-cost-of-charging/107175852

Why do you say that? I see good advice.

It is good advice. Pretty obvious most of it but I guess a lot of people don’t know some of those tricks.
FWIW they’ll also keep driving when the battery hit 0%. Not for long but there’s almost always a few additional K’s you can get access to.

Spocky & I took the latest BYD Atto 1 for a drive last week and it was just fine for around town stuff. The base model doesn’t have a huge range so I wouldn’t be going to Brisbane & back in it but it’s fine for shorter trips.
The regen is only either on or off and when it’s on it doesn’t have a great deal of retardation, so you still have to tickle the brake pedal in traffic.
When we left the dealership it has 208 km on the range, after about 3 km of driving (a fair bit a gentle downhill and in traffic) it got up to 211 km. A run down the highway then on some slower road to get back had the final range at 203 km, which was pretty good after a 10 km drive I thought.

We’re debating whether to get a brand new one of those (Only $20,000 on-road!) or a second-hand Leaf at about $14,000.
At the moment I favour the Leaf.

Seems okay to me

Thanks for that review.

OK then, how good is the advice¿ Because qualitative assertions without quantitative backing are a disinformation tactic. So tell us, how much more value are you squeezing out with each of their suggestions¿

Yeah yeah it’s easy to criticise so here we’ll put our necks out on the line for yous, we challenge you to quantify where we’re wrong with these don’t-even-have-an-envelope estimates (fuck engineers hey).

Regenerative braking. Any good EV will do as much of its braking regeneratively as possible, so that mechanical brakes only kick in at full stop or emergency slam. There’s no comparison so as they say, either it’s on or it’s off, and it should be on.

Using the brake as little as possible. OK now we’re talking. Conserving momentum is better than electrical transmission and battery losses. Savings of 30%.

Avoiding the temptation to make a fast getaway at every set of traffic lights. Resistive losses are negligible. This will save you jack all, but sure, maybe 5% to 10% if you’re lucky. Closer to the 5% mark, but not even because you won’t be stopped at lights if you drive properly conserving momentum anyway, you won’t be the first in line if you do stop, and you won’t floor it even then because you’ll just run up the arse of the next donkey.

Where you’re driving. “When you’re out on the freeway driving, they’re less efficient … you’re sapping a lot of energy from the battery so your range will diminish more quickly.” Fine, we’ll be generous, this is misinformation, since we can’t outright prejudge disinformation. Your range will diminish because you’re using it. It’s just as efficient. It looks different (opposite) to pure ICE vehicles because the burners actually lose efficiency when they’re not cruising. The gap narrows. It’s not because batteries get worse.

“The best thing to do is actually just slow down.”. For saving power, yes. No shit. “Even from 100 going down to 70 will actually give you a lot more range.” Correct. You’d save close to, even over, 50% doing that. “Turning off your air con and other unnecessary add-ons can help too, but speed is “by far” the biggest drain, Mr Siem says.” Exfuckingactly.

Add ons. Air conditioning is the big one, in everyday units thermal energy is 1000 times more significant than mechanical energy, so yeah be careful with that. Other accessories 5% if you’re lucky.

Tyre pressure. In a drivable range, 5%. If you want to risk a blowout or destroying your suspension, more.

Weight (mass). Fuck all. Effectively neutralised by regenerative braking. Adds zero to drag, which is the major cost. Otherwise similar effect to flooring it at the lights: 10% if you’re lucky.

Aerodynamic drag. Well yes, it’s the bit that combines with speed to burn off all your energy. Roof racks will fuck you up like 30%. Otherwise people don’t generally change the shape of their car much. Don’t drive with your doors wide open like air brakes.

Any objections about needing a ¿ref for any of that, come at us about disinformation then, let’s go.

Reply Quote View full thread