captain_spalding said:
party_pants said:
I hve given up on Australia ever having a fixed wing aircraft carrier again, unless it is drones and not any human piloted aircraft.There is now a certain minimum size I think, something like the French one. But they are unaffordable for a country like us.
The new British carriers are a disaster. Was initially going to be a conventional design with catapults and arrested landing etc. As a cost saving measure they decided to go with the ski jump and STOVL only. Only one aircraft that could that was the F-35 B, but they were so delayed and so expensive that the UK halved the number they had ordered as a further cost saving measure. They don’t have enough F-35 Bs to make the carriers worth the effort. They are reliant on US Marines to provide the airwing in times of crisis. Instead of the glorious names they have given this class, they really should be called the HMS Inadequate and the HMS Inforrepairs, given how often they break down.
With the coastline that Australia has, and the sea areas that its Navy has to operate in, Australia really needs three carriers (there was a very brief halcyon moment in the mid-1950s when this was the case).
They need not be enormous carriers, but could be rather more economically-sized.
The Spanish are not bad at this. They had their ‘Principe de Asturias’
and currently have the Juan Carlos 1, an LHD the same as Australia’s, operating AV-8B S/VTO L aircraft (something which the RAAF will tell you is impossible).
The Italians had the Giuseppe Garibaldi
and currently have the Cavour, which is only 1,000 tonnes more than the LHDs.
Surely, either the Italians or the Spanish could design a neat, economical, less-than-gigantic carrier for Australia? Then, we might have three of the: one in the east, one in the west, one in refit.
The problem is what aircraft to operate from it. Right now there is only the F-35 B. I’d rather not go down that path. They will never be a sovereign asset for any country (apart from the US). Too many strings attached and a long and slow supply chain back to the US for parts and spares. Plus the issue of software patches and file updates, that’s all from the US too. We could never operate them independently of Washington. Higher priority IMHO is to have a back-up for the F-35 A for the RAAF that we can operate and maintain locally.
That’s if we need manned aircraft at all anymore. I’d like for us to go with lots and lotsa drones and hypersonic missiles. Plus our own nuclear weapons.



