captain_spalding said:
Spiny Norman said:
captain_spalding said:One thing that the Falklands showed is that supersonic is not always necessary.
Sea Harriers, a firmly sub-supersonic aircraft, shot down 20 confirmed Argentine aircraft, of which 10 were supersonic-capable Mirage variants.
What really matters is manoeuvrability.
True but speed is energy and it gives you more options. A fighter down around 150 kts isn’t going to be able to dodge much or turn well.
There’s a very important thing called corner speed and that’s the speed where you can pull maximum G’s in a turn without stalling the wing or over-G’ing the airframe.
It’s usually around 350 – 400 kts.
Below that speed you can of course make a tighter radius turn, so it’s acceptable to reduce speed but you have to make sure it’s going to work or it may well go against you.
The only figure i can find for a Harrier is for the AV-8B, with a max turn rate of 45°/s at 200 knots, 8.0g load factor, and 82.8° bank. Low speed, but good.
Of course, Harriers have the trick of Vectoring In Forward Flight (VIFFing) up their sleeve, meaning rapid deceleration, effectively stopping in mid-air, which no supersonic fighter can do. This creates a set of options of its own.
It may have contributed much to the number of Sea Harriers that the Argentine aircraft shot down.
Zero.
Yep.
They could certainly slow down much faster than any other fighter – but again you really have to make it count – energy is life.
They’d accelerate quite nicely though, with a very good power-to-weight ratio.
It reminds me of the famous scene in Top Gun, when Maverick suddenly pitches the F-14 up so that it slows down very quickly from the high drag. Against a skilled opponent, all that’s likely to do it make you a better target.