Kingy said:
You have mentioned a few times previously about the people in charge of the nukes who have sworn an oath to the US of A, not the mentally deranged child who has been voted in by other mentally deranged voters.
The grown-ups in charge of the nukes are not likely to hand them over to this imbecile to launch them at the kid who stole your lunch money when you were 5 years old.
There’s arguments and counter-arguments that could fuel a debate. The people concerned have a quandary
Briefly, the military people swore an oath to defend their Constitution, and to defend it from enemies both foreign and domestic. In the same oath, there is the declaration that the person will obey the orders of the President of the United States. That’s because the Prez is the Commander-in-Chief, named as such in the US Constitution.
But, what if a President’s orders a quite clearly without good reason and/or to the detriment of the US and its citizens?
The law is quite clear: for orders that are merely unwise or harmful but not patently illegal, the military is legally obligated to comply.
The US Manual for Courts-Martial states explicitly:
“The dictates of a person’s conscience, religion, or personal philosophy cannot justify or excuse the disobedience of an otherwise lawful order.”
So the legal threshold is “patently unlawful” — an order that a person of ordinary sense would recognize as criminal (e.g., ordering the killing of civilians, torture, targeting political opponents). A president who orders something detrimental to the US — a wasteful war, a harmful economic sanction, a politically motivated deployment — but which doesn’t clearly violate a statute or constitutional provision, must be obeyed under current law. Disobeying such an order exposes the service member to court-martial under Articles 90 and 92 of the UCMJ.
However, all is not necessarily lost. There is something beyond the strict legal minimum:
Professional/ethical duty: Army doctrine grants officers “moral autonomy” and obligates them to challenge orders “likely to harm the institution writ large—the Nation, military, and subordinates—in a manner not clearly outweighed by its likely benefits.” This is an ethical, not a legal, obligation — it doesn’t protect the officer from punishment, but it provides professional justification.
Again, much depends on the people concerned, where they see themslves in the situation, and on their character and ethics.