The Rev Dodgson said:
the history of the Brachistochrone.
What was so special about Isaac Newton’s solution to the Brachistochrone problem that impressed Johann Bernoulli?
Primarily, that Newton had offered an elegant geometric argument coupled with his “fluxions” (differential calculus). Bernoulli himself had previously solved the problem, but in a very different manner, treating it as a physical problem by analogy to light traveling through layers of glass and applying Fermat’s principle of least time. Effectively, Bernoulli translated the problem into a problem of optics, applied Snell’s law, and obtained a differential equation that he recognized as a kind of cycloid curve.
Bernoulli challenged European mathematicians to also solve the problem in 1696, giving them six months to find the curve of fastest descent.
Newton sent his solution to the Earl of Halifax, who was also the President of the Royal Society at the time. The society then published Newton’s solution in the Transactions, but did so anonymously. Bernoulli recognized the style immediately and knew it was Newton, famously saying, “I recognize the lion by his claw.”
You will see answers that claim that Bernoulli was primarily impressed by the speed of Newton’s solution, which supposedly happened in a single night, but that comes from Newton’s biographer. Bernoulli may have worked out how fast Newton solved it, but only by working backwards from the timeline of publication in the Transactions, and the fact that the problem had only been known in Britain for a short time, after Bernoulli’s six month window had expired and Leibniz asked for it to be extended.
so can they explain the solution like we’re 5 years old