Appealed on seven grounds:
The “Hotel Error” (Compromised Jury): Defence lawyers argued there was a “fundamental irregularity” and a “catastrophic” failure of the justice system during jury sequestration. Due to accommodation shortages in the Gippsland region caused by a national table tennis tournament, the jurors stayed at the same hotel as the lead police witness, two members of the prosecution team, and media reporters while deliberating their verdicts.
Unfair Cross-Examination: Her team argued that the five-day cross-examination of Patterson by prosecutor Nanette Rogers was “unfair and oppressive,” creating an unbalanced trial environment.
Contradictory Arguments Over Motive: The defence claimed a substantial miscarriage of justice occurred because the prosecution explicitly opened the trial stating they did not need to prove a motive, but then pivoted during closing addresses to aggressively imply Patterson was motivated by an active family child-support dispute.
Wrongful Admission of Mobile Tower Data: They argued that large tranches of technical evidence—specifically mobile phone tower tracking data tying her movements to rural Gippsland areas where death cap mushrooms grow—should never have been shown to the jury.
Exclusion of Exculpatory Foraging Evidence: Her lawyers argued the trial judge erred by ruling out photos and videos found on Patterson’s electronic devices (including an SD card) from 2020, which her team claimed could have supported her defense that she was a harmless, long-time mushroom forager.
Prejudicial Facebook Evidence: They asserted that personal messages and rants about her estranged husband and in-laws sourced from Facebook “friends” and groups were legally irrelevant, and that their highly prejudicial nature completely outweighed any actual value to the case
Overreach in the Prosecution’s Closing Address: The final ground targeted what the defence identified as up to 35 separate instances of errors, speculative claims, and prejudicial overreach made by the Crown during their final closing address to the jury.
—-
on the long time mushroom forager point – she told the police that she did not go foraging in an interview.