Date: 30/10/2026 12:08:38
From: buffy
ID: 2443712
Subject: re: Erin Patterson Sentencing

Arts said:


Cymek said:

Cymek said:

Always a worry with appeal like this you get even stricter sentencing

As an experience mushroom forager it could work against you as you’d be aware of the poisonous ones and less likely to accidentally pick them.

that’s true, but my understanding is that even experienced foragers can be mistaken with this particular mushroom (Buffy might be able to correct or confirm)
, the point is that EP said she was not experienced (at the same time she told them she didn’t have a dehydrator) and part of her appeal is her trying to establish foraging experience. it’s straw clasping at this point.

in any case, she can now lodge a special leave application – these have super strict legal thresholds… or if there is new evidence that is ‘fresh and compelling’ she can launch an appeal then too…

otherwise, she has pretty much set her fate now.

I’m not actually a forager – I’m much too risk averse for that. I do think I could ID a deathcap and have done so on iNaturalist, but there are a lot of white Amanita mushrooms. It would be easy to make a mistake.

Reply Quote View full thread