Date: 1/11/2026 18:07:05
From: Spiny Norman
ID: 2444476
Subject: re: Spiny's thread of occasional interest

Will AI Replace Engineers? I Ran the Experiment

This vacuum cleaner does not exist. AI agents designed it: the housing, the airflow, the structure, the circuit board, the firmware. From one prompt, in about 31 hours. And the TV ad for it? They made that too.

I teach engineers, so this question is personal: is engineering the next profession AI takes over? I gave Claude Code one long brief, let it run a whole engineering department of AI agents (a manager and seven specialists working in FreeCAD, OpenFOAM, CalculiX, KiCad and Blender), and then I checked their work.

It failed a safety test, and said so. Things broke. It missed five mistakes that I spotted in one minute. And when three engineers looked at the result, one of them could not even read it. What they said comes at the end. After that, I show you how to build this yourself, step by step.

In this video:
• One message, eight agents: how the department was set up
• A CFD simulation that changed the geometry
• An honest FAIL in the stress analysis
• The circuit board, the firmware, and a test result that corrected the boss
• What broke, and what caught it
• What the agents cannot see: the AI TV spot for 18 dollars
• Would it work? Three engineers answer
• Is engineering next? My verdict
• Build it yourself: terminal, agent, tools, prompt

YT

Reply Quote View full thread