Date: 5/08/2019 20:44:59
From: Tau.Neutrino
ID: 1419295
Subject: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

A genetic mutation that slowed down the development of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) in two or more children may have triggered a cascade of events leading to acquisition of recursive language and modern imagination 70,000 years ago.

more…

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 21:03:46
From: Tau.Neutrino
ID: 1419303
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Modern farming around that period may have given the children more time on a daily basis to interact with each other through storytelling. Storytelling needs juxtaposition of mental objects, perhaps the epigenetics involved around all of that created the mutation.?

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:21:59
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 1419338
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Tau.Neutrino said:


Modern farming around that period may have given the children more time on a daily basis to interact with each other through storytelling. Storytelling needs juxtaposition of mental objects, perhaps the epigenetics involved around all of that created the mutation.?

Modern farming 70,000 years ago? I don’t think so.

Apart from which, the evidence would seem to suggest that a hunter-gatherer lifestyle is more likely to promote story telling.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:29:52
From: dv
ID: 1419343
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

All of this sounds very dodgy.

“On the other hand, artifacts signifying modern imagination, such as composite figurative arts, elaborate burials, bone needles with an eye, and construction of dwellings arose not earlier than 70,000 years ago. The half million-year-gap between the acquisition of the modern speech apparatus and modern imagination has baffled scientists for decades.”

But why? These cultural features arose at different times in different areas, despite the rapid spread of genetic variations. It’s quite a leap to put it down to some genetic factor for “imagination”.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:32:04
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 1419344
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

dv said:


All of this sounds very dodgy.

“On the other hand, artifacts signifying modern imagination, such as composite figurative arts, elaborate burials, bone needles with an eye, and construction of dwellings arose not earlier than 70,000 years ago. The half million-year-gap between the acquisition of the modern speech apparatus and modern imagination has baffled scientists for decades.”

But why? These cultural features arose at different times in different areas, despite the rapid spread of genetic variations. It’s quite a leap to put it down to some genetic factor for “imagination”.

… and there is mounting evidence of those things starting to develop much earlier than 70,000 years ago anyway.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:36:47
From: dv
ID: 1419346
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

The Rev Dodgson said:


dv said:

All of this sounds very dodgy.

“On the other hand, artifacts signifying modern imagination, such as composite figurative arts, elaborate burials, bone needles with an eye, and construction of dwellings arose not earlier than 70,000 years ago. The half million-year-gap between the acquisition of the modern speech apparatus and modern imagination has baffled scientists for decades.”

But why? These cultural features arose at different times in different areas, despite the rapid spread of genetic variations. It’s quite a leap to put it down to some genetic factor for “imagination”.

… and there is mounting evidence of those things starting to develop much earlier than 70,000 years ago anyway.

Quite.

I mean if there was some “bing” moment of very rapid widespread development then this would be worth listening to, but that’s not how it was. There was a slow burn of tool and technique development from Australopethicus onwards: admittedly, hastening, but never hitting a sharp inflection point until the development of proper agriculture.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:40:07
From: Bubblecar
ID: 1419349
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

>The half million-year-gap between the acquisition of the modern speech apparatus and modern imagination has baffled scientists for decades.

Not it hasn’t. Scientists realise that there are many uses of the imagination that don’t result in durable artefacts, or any artefacts. Stories, songs, paintings in the sand etc could have been going for hundreds of thousands of years.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 22:52:32
From: Bubblecar
ID: 1419364
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Look at the technology involved in indigenous Australian stories, song and dance. Simple wooden instruments, body paint, costumes made from feathers and other organic material. Rich and complicated stories handed down orally, bark paintings, sand art.

None of that is at all likely to survive in the archaeological record. Only some examples of rock art have survived, associated with special sites. But the less durable art could have been going for a long time before then.

Reply Quote

Date: 5/08/2019 23:20:35
From: transition
ID: 1419377
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

imagine, some mutation that caused beneficial delayed development

hope for me yet

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 02:23:33
From: roughbarked
ID: 1419430
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

transition said:


imagine, some mutation that caused beneficial delayed development

hope for me yet

maybe for me as well?

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 02:26:12
From: roughbarked
ID: 1419431
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Bubblecar said:


Look at the technology involved in indigenous Australian stories, song and dance. Simple wooden instruments, body paint, costumes made from feathers and other organic material. Rich and complicated stories handed down orally, bark paintings, sand art.

None of that is at all likely to survive in the archaeological record. Only some examples of rock art have survived, associated with special sites. But the less durable art could have been going for a long time before then.

We would have been entirely at a loss if it had turned out to be Terra nullius and all we could find was the art and sites.

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 10:13:19
From: Cymek
ID: 1419452
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

The Rev Dodgson said:


Tau.Neutrino said:

Modern farming around that period may have given the children more time on a daily basis to interact with each other through storytelling. Storytelling needs juxtaposition of mental objects, perhaps the epigenetics involved around all of that created the mutation.?

Modern farming 70,000 years ago? I don’t think so.

Apart from which, the evidence would seem to suggest that a hunter-gatherer lifestyle is more likely to promote story telling.

Yes stories about how huge the one that got away was

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 10:43:11
From: Peak Warming Man
ID: 1419464
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

The Rev Dodgson said:


Tau.Neutrino said:

Modern farming around that period may have given the children more time on a daily basis to interact with each other through storytelling. Storytelling needs juxtaposition of mental objects, perhaps the epigenetics involved around all of that created the mutation.?

Modern farming 70,000 years ago? I don’t think so.

Apart from which, the evidence would seem to suggest that a hunter-gatherer lifestyle is more likely to promote story telling.

When the earth was young and we were dim
Survival was our only thing
We had no time to grow our brain
Until that is we p0lanted grain
Time to wonder, time to ponder

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 10:59:03
From: transition
ID: 1419471
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

so the window for juggling grunts, the order of grunts, the pointing potentials of word-concepts, some changed were happened upon, accidents of birth so to speak, and I gather psychological mindedness was born too.

and so recently, barely time to proliferate.

Reply Quote

Date: 6/08/2019 11:46:13
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 1419487
Subject: re: Recursive language and modern imagination were acquired simultaneously 70,000 years ago

Peak Warming Man said:


The Rev Dodgson said:

Tau.Neutrino said:

Modern farming around that period may have given the children more time on a daily basis to interact with each other through storytelling. Storytelling needs juxtaposition of mental objects, perhaps the epigenetics involved around all of that created the mutation.?

Modern farming 70,000 years ago? I don’t think so.

Apart from which, the evidence would seem to suggest that a hunter-gatherer lifestyle is more likely to promote story telling.

When the earth was young and we were dim
Survival was our only thing
We had no time to grow our brain
Until that is we p0lanted grain
Time to wonder, time to ponder

Obviously the words of a grainist.

Reply Quote