mollwollfumble said:
Tamb said:
When I was a teen I read Asimov, EE Doc Smith, Michael Moorcock, Philip K. Dick, John Wyndham, Ray Bradbury, Arthur C. Clarke….Dr Who books
All except Dr Who.
There used to be a really good list of top SciFi books. A list not written by one person but polled from perhaps many thousand responses. I voted for my favourites including:
EE Smith “Galactic Patrol”,
Herbert “Dune”
Joan D Vinge “Catspaw”
Sherry S Tepper “Grass”
Stross “Glasshouse”
Heinlein “Moon is a harsh mistress”
Douglas Adams “HHGTTG”.
I also have some favourites that nobody votes for:
Rotsler “The far frontier”
Poul Anderson “After doomsday”
Maccaffrey and Moon “Sassinak”
Philip E High “Come, hunt an earthman”
Piers Anthony “Mercycle”
Donal Moffitt “The Jupiter theft”
Andre Norton “Voorloper”
Steve Perry “The man who never missed”
All the above, IMHO, are better than “Enders game” which itself isn’t too bad.
In order to know whether a SciFi book is good, you have to read it twice. Some books I thoroughly enjoyed on first reading, but not on second reading. The following fail the “second reading” test.
Asimov – all
Arthur C Clark – “Rendezvous with Rama”
Arthur C Clark – “A fall of moondust”
Anne McCaffrey – “The ship who sang”
Madelaine Le Engel – “A wrinkle in time”
Joan D Vinge – “The Snow Queen”
C J Cherryh – “Cyteen”
“Enders game”
“Neuromancer”
Some SciFi books I really want to read a second time but haven’t yet.
Dr Who series – “Spiral Scratch”
Anne McCaffrey – “Crystal Singer”
Sherri S Tepper – “The True Game”
Heinlein – “Time enough for love”
There are some good postmodern 21st century SciFi writers, see:
“Twenty-First Century Science Fiction: An Anthology”
There is one good-bad book I want to mention. It’s CJ Cherryh “Forty Thousand in Gehenna”. The book is abysmally badly written, but the concept of a new method of alien communication is superb.