Date: 13/07/2022 20:32:08
From: transition
ID: 1908282
Subject: some study of pointing

briefly going past some skippies today, way over otherside the paddock

little one stood up, seem to point in the direction of an approaching larger roo

skippies point all the time, their faces, eyes, ears, noses, even mouths, they point their arms and paws to walk, when they fight they point their limbs etc

so what’s the possibility little skippy is pointing toward the approaching roo, the bigger one in the inset as circled came over

Reply Quote

Date: 13/07/2022 20:40:23
From: Bubblecar
ID: 1908286
Subject: re: some study of pointing

transition said:


briefly going past some skippies today, way over otherside the paddock

little one stood up, seem to point in the direction of an approaching larger roo

skippies point all the time, their faces, eyes, ears, noses, even mouths, they point their arms and paws to walk, when they fight they point their limbs etc

so what’s the possibility little skippy is pointing toward the approaching roo, the bigger one in the inset as circled came over


Possibly a welcoming signal to the larger roo?

Reply Quote

Date: 13/07/2022 20:44:30
From: Bogsnorkler
ID: 1908290
Subject: re: some study of pointing

anthropomorphising. most likely.

Reply Quote

Date: 13/07/2022 21:12:16
From: transition
ID: 1908303
Subject: re: some study of pointing

Bogsnorkler said:


anthropomorphising. most likely.

in the most basic sense (say of limbs here, of the example, for the moment), pointing need only be reaching out toward

Reply Quote

Date: 14/07/2022 03:23:22
From: mollwollfumble
ID: 1908380
Subject: re: some study of pointing

Animal behaviour, good stuff.

Animals do most of what humans do.

Reply Quote

Date: 14/07/2022 03:29:52
From: roughbarked
ID: 1908381
Subject: re: some study of pointing

mollwollfumble said:


Animal behaviour, good stuff.

Animals do most of what humans do.

Humans are animals.

Reply Quote

Date: 14/07/2022 06:58:28
From: SCIENCE
ID: 1908386
Subject: re: some study of pointing

but some of them are potatoes

Reply Quote

Date: 15/07/2022 05:48:51
From: mollwollfumble
ID: 1908852
Subject: re: some study of pointing

roughbarked said:


mollwollfumble said:

Animal behaviour, good stuff.

Animals do most of what humans do.

Humans are animals.

There is a not-so-familiar but extremely common logic fault here.

(All) humans are animals does not imply that (all) animals are humans.

And saying “animals do most of what humans to” Is logically equivalent to “non-human animals do most of what humans do” + “humans do what humans do”. So saying “non-human animals do most of what humans do” is unnecessarily exclusive.

Reply Quote

Date: 15/07/2022 06:38:04
From: roughbarked
ID: 1908854
Subject: re: some study of pointing

mollwollfumble said:


roughbarked said:

mollwollfumble said:

Animal behaviour, good stuff.

Animals do most of what humans do.

Humans are animals.

There is a not-so-familiar but extremely common logic fault here.

(All) humans are animals does not imply that (all) animals are humans.

And saying “animals do most of what humans to” Is logically equivalent to “non-human animals do most of what humans do” + “humans do what humans do”. So saying “non-human animals do most of what humans do” is unnecessarily exclusive.

So WTF did you say it then?

Reply Quote