Date: 1/09/2024 23:55:43
From: dv
ID: 2192215
Subject: Comparative genomics

The Hard Quiz included this question:

How much DNA do humans share with monkeys?

The options were 64%, 84%, 93%, 99%.

(Humans are more closely related to Old World monkeys (most recent common ancestor ~25 mya) than New World monkeys (mrca ~40 mya), so I suppose they meant the Old World monkeys. But this is by the by.)

OCDC, roughbarked and I objected to this.

I can’t speak for them but my objection was that, taken literally, the amount of shared DNA between humans and monkeys is less than 3%.

The question should probably have been worded: How genetically similar are humans and monkeys? What percentage of protein-coding genes are shared between humans and monkeys.
Protein-coding genes only make up a small percentage of DNA.

Science communicators often misrepresent these concepts.

Reply Quote

Date: 2/09/2024 01:11:30
From: SCIENCE
ID: 2192221
Subject: re: Comparative genomics

how do they arrive at each of those 64%, 84%, 93%, 99%, 3% figures

Reply Quote

Date: 2/09/2024 07:09:39
From: roughbarked
ID: 2192225
Subject: re: Comparative genomics

dv said:


The Hard Quiz included this question:

How much DNA do humans share with monkeys?

The options were 64%, 84%, 93%, 99%.

(Humans are more closely related to Old World monkeys (most recent common ancestor ~25 mya) than New World monkeys (mrca ~40 mya), so I suppose they meant the Old World monkeys. But this is by the by.)

OCDC, roughbarked and I objected to this.

I can’t speak for them but my objection was that, taken literally, the amount of shared DNA between humans and monkeys is less than 3%.

The question should probably have been worded: How genetically similar are humans and monkeys? What percentage of protein-coding genes are shared between humans and monkeys.
Protein-coding genes only make up a small percentage of DNA.

Science communicators often misrepresent these concepts.

It appears that: The ABC research tem let Tom Gleeson down.

Reply Quote

Date: 2/09/2024 07:27:00
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 2192228
Subject: re: Comparative genomics

roughbarked said:


dv said:

The Hard Quiz included this question:

How much DNA do humans share with monkeys?

The options were 64%, 84%, 93%, 99%.

(Humans are more closely related to Old World monkeys (most recent common ancestor ~25 mya) than New World monkeys (mrca ~40 mya), so I suppose they meant the Old World monkeys. But this is by the by.)

OCDC, roughbarked and I objected to this.

I can’t speak for them but my objection was that, taken literally, the amount of shared DNA between humans and monkeys is less than 3%.

The question should probably have been worded: How genetically similar are humans and monkeys? What percentage of protein-coding genes are shared between humans and monkeys.
Protein-coding genes only make up a small percentage of DNA.

Science communicators often misrepresent these concepts.

It appears that: The ABC research tem let Tom Gleeson down.

… and dv omitted an objector from his list.

Reply Quote

Date: 2/09/2024 07:34:20
From: roughbarked
ID: 2192231
Subject: re: Comparative genomics

The Rev Dodgson said:


roughbarked said:

dv said:

The Hard Quiz included this question:

How much DNA do humans share with monkeys?

The options were 64%, 84%, 93%, 99%.

(Humans are more closely related to Old World monkeys (most recent common ancestor ~25 mya) than New World monkeys (mrca ~40 mya), so I suppose they meant the Old World monkeys. But this is by the by.)

OCDC, roughbarked and I objected to this.

I can’t speak for them but my objection was that, taken literally, the amount of shared DNA between humans and monkeys is less than 3%.

The question should probably have been worded: How genetically similar are humans and monkeys? What percentage of protein-coding genes are shared between humans and monkeys.
Protein-coding genes only make up a small percentage of DNA.

Science communicators often misrepresent these concepts.

It appears that: The ABC research tem let Tom Gleeson down.

… and dv omitted an objector from his list.

I Feel for your plight.

Reply Quote

Date: 3/09/2024 19:29:56
From: wookiemeister
ID: 2192768
Subject: re: Comparative genomics

Men were engineered not evolved

Reply Quote