Is this one?

bubba louie said:

Is this one?

I think it’s not. I’ve done some googling and there are a few other possibilities.

The leaves look a bit big, otherwise I’d suggest a guava? I’m sure I’ve read about a guava apple somewhere…

Morning all. Yes I think it is. Have a look at these:

http://www.thaiworldview.com/food3.htm

http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/9HzMK0l_jYGncYUK0lwkog

http://www.khmerkromrecipes.com/pages/fruits.html

Dinetta said:

The leaves look a bit big, otherwise I’d suggest a guava? I’m sure I’ve read about a guava apple somewhere…

Not a Guava.

AnneS said:

Morning all. Yes I think it is. Have a look at these:

http://www.thaiworldview.com/food3.htm

http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/9HzMK0l_jYGncYUK0lwkog

http://www.khmerkromrecipes.com/pages/fruits.html

It’s the old common name thing. Rose Apple here seems to be S. jambos, which isn’t this one. i think it’s called Malay Apple here. There’s a few that are very similar.

Well their custard apple is “cherimoya” (this is the last link I am speaking of), their “custard apple” has a weird skin colour (white?) and their papaya doesn’t look like any that I’m familiar with…mind you I agree that your Rose Apple looks very much like theirs…

Rose Apple here is Syzygium jambos. Wax Jambos is Syzygium jambolana, which looks more likely. Malay Apple, Syzygium malaccense. Java Apple, S. samarangense.

My brain hurts.

bubba louie said:

Rose Apple here is Syzygium jambos. Wax Jambos is Syzygium jambolana, which looks more likely. Malay Apple, Syzygium malaccense. Java Apple, S. samarangense.

My brain hurts.

the old Rose Apple chestnut eh? S. jambos is good a place to start… I have seen a few, and eaten many, watched TC Larry smash them apart and have thrown others at PNGeans.

Yours look too small. They look almost like S. australe. I like to eat Laulaus.

pain master said:

bubba louie said:

Rose Apple here is Syzygium jambos. Wax Jambos is Syzygium jambolana, which looks more likely. Malay Apple, Syzygium malaccense. Java Apple, S. samarangense.

My brain hurts.

the old Rose Apple chestnut eh? S. jambos is good a place to start… I have seen a few, and eaten many, watched TC Larry smash them apart and have thrown others at PNGeans.

Yours look too small. They look almost like S. australe. I like to eat Laulaus.

They aren’t small. I’ve seen austral and these are many many times bigger.

bubba louie said:

pain master said:

bubba louie said:

Rose Apple here is Syzygium jambos. Wax Jambos is Syzygium jambolana, which looks more likely. Malay Apple, Syzygium malaccense. Java Apple, S. samarangense.

My brain hurts.

the old Rose Apple chestnut eh? S. jambos is good a place to start… I have seen a few, and eaten many, watched TC Larry smash them apart and have thrown others at PNGeans.

Yours look too small. They look almost like S. australe. I like to eat Laulaus.

They aren’t small. I’ve seen austral and these are many many times bigger.

almost look like Laulaus to me.

Hang on, let me check my PNG notes.

pain master said:

bubba louie said:

pain master said:

the old Rose Apple chestnut eh? S. jambos is good a place to start… I have seen a few, and eaten many, watched TC Larry smash them apart and have thrown others at PNGeans.

Yours look too small. They look almost like S. australe. I like to eat Laulaus.

They aren’t small. I’ve seen austral and these are many many times bigger.

almost look like Laulaus to me.

Hang on, let me check my PNG notes.

Laulaus are S. jambolanum.

Mountain apple which is different is Eugenia malaccensis

pain master said:

pain master said:

bubba louie said:

They aren’t small. I’ve seen austral and these are many many times bigger.

almost look like Laulaus to me.

Hang on, let me check my PNG notes.

Laulaus are S. jambolanum.

Mountain apple which is different is Eugenia malaccensis

Check out S. samarangense.

bubba louie said:

pain master said:

pain master said:

almost look like Laulaus to me.

Hang on, let me check my PNG notes.

Laulaus are S. jambolanum.

Mountain apple which is different is Eugenia malaccensis

Check out S. samarangense.

Looks good bubba :)

pain master said:

bubba louie said:

pain master said:

Laulaus are S. jambolanum.

Mountain apple which is different is Eugenia malaccensis

Check out S. samarangense.

Looks good bubba :)

It was a pretty tree.