Date: 12/10/2013 04:12:12
From: mollwollfumble
ID: 411482
Subject: GPS map question?

If you have a GPS map, any brand other than Go-Cruise (Aldi), then please check the following for Bowral, NSW.

Does Shepherd St connect to Old South Rd?
Does McDonald St connect Bowral St to Merrigang St?
Does Albert St connect Bowral St to Merrigang St?
Does Ivy St connect Shepherd St to Merrigang St?
Does Gibraltar Rd connect Merrigang St to Duke St?

The correct answer is no, no, no, no, no.
Go-Cruise GPS says yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

I need to know how global the error is in order to know who can fix it. What does your GPS say?

I already know that Wingecarribee Council maps are the source of the error. Some over-zealous employee more than 20 years ago marked proposed roads as if they actually existed. There are no plans to build these proposed roads, sometimes the routes aren’t even possible any more, Ivy and Albert Streets have houses built across the road line. Google Earth/Maps has it close to correct (the gaps are there but sometimes they’re the wrong length).

Reply Quote

Date: 12/10/2013 08:53:48
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 411491
Subject: re: GPS map question?

mollwollfumble said:


If you have a GPS map, any brand other than Go-Cruise (Aldi), then please check the following for Bowral, NSW.

Does Shepherd St connect to Old South Rd?
Does McDonald St connect Bowral St to Merrigang St?
Does Albert St connect Bowral St to Merrigang St?
Does Ivy St connect Shepherd St to Merrigang St?
Does Gibraltar Rd connect Merrigang St to Duke St?

The correct answer is no, no, no, no, no.
Go-Cruise GPS says yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

I need to know how global the error is in order to know who can fix it. What does your GPS say?

I already know that Wingecarribee Council maps are the source of the error. Some over-zealous employee more than 20 years ago marked proposed roads as if they actually existed. There are no plans to build these proposed roads, sometimes the routes aren’t even possible any more, Ivy and Albert Streets have houses built across the road line. Google Earth/Maps has it close to correct (the gaps are there but sometimes they’re the wrong length).

On Google Maps:

No
No
No
No
No

Reads the end of the OP.

Oh, you already knew that.

Reply Quote

Date: 12/10/2013 10:21:27
From: captain_spalding
ID: 411497
Subject: re: GPS map question?

Sometimes the Council maps show what’s been gazetted as road or road reserve, but that doesn’t mean that everything on those maps has actually been constructed yet.

It’s so you can see what’s set aside as road, for future planning.

Reply Quote

Date: 12/10/2013 13:10:18
From: neomyrtus_
ID: 411566
Subject: re: GPS map question?

captain_spalding said:


Sometimes the Council maps show what’s been gazetted as road or road reserve, but that doesn’t mean that everything on those maps has actually been constructed yet.

It’s so you can see what’s set aside as road, for future planning.

this is common – see “paper roads”. Some last for decades on maps. Another issue is when a cartography service will draw in a road / track from aerial imagery without groundtruthing. There’s tracks on old forestry topos which we found don’t exist probably because of this error.

Reply Quote

Date: 12/10/2013 14:18:53
From: Rule 303
ID: 411610
Subject: re: GPS map question?

The 2012 NAVTEQ maps in my Garmin Navigator show the streets in grey (the others around them are white).

Reply Quote