Scientists pinpoint when humans had babies with Neanderthals
Neanderthals interbred with modern humans 47,000 years ago, passing down DNA that still exists in many modern-day people, according to two new studies.
December 12, 2024 at 2:00 p.m. EST Today at 2:00 p.m. EST
By Carolyn Y. Johnson
A pair of new studies sheds light on a pivotal but mysterious chapter of the human origin story, revealing that modern humans and Neanderthals had babies together for an extended period, peaking 47,000 years ago — leaving genetic fingerprints in modern-day people.
You are what you read. Reveal your 2024 reader type with Newsprint.
Scientists have long known that Neanderthals and humans had offspring and that among them were our ancestors. Today, people from around the world who are descended from the group of humans that left Africa and successfully settled Eurasia still contain a vestige of Neanderthal DNA in their genomes.
But the timing and specifics of these interspecies pairings have been debated. The new results, published Thursday in the journals Science and Nature, don’t upend our understanding of this period but enrich it with complexities and details.
To gain greater insight, one group of scientists analyzed genomes from 275 present-day and 59 prehistoric humans who lived between 2,200 and 45,000 years ago, looking for segments of Neanderthal DNA and trying to estimate when they entered the human genome. They report in Science that Neanderthals and humans interbred for 7,000 years starting about 50,500 years ago.
A second group of researchers disclosed in Nature a new line of evidence by sequencing the oldest human genomes yet, bringing to life a 45,000-year-old human family, including a mother and baby whose Neanderthal ancestry traced to 80 generations earlier.
“It paints a different story than this rare encounter. Whenever you ran into a Neanderthal, it was okay to have a baby with a Neanderthal,” said Fernando Villanea, an anthropologist at the University of Colorado at Boulder who was not involved in the studies. “It just paints this story that makes sense to how the real world works. For a long period of time, humans were running into Neanderthals, and they were having babies.”
Using DNA to time travel
Modern humans, Homo sapiens, originated in Africa about 300,000 years ago. Somewhere around 50,000 to 60,000 years ago, a key group left the continent and encountered Neanderthals, a hominin relative that was established across western Eurasia but went extinct about 39,000 years ago.
Neanderthals have often been caricatured as brutish and primitive, and for years scientists debated whether they ever interbred with humans.
Research into ancient DNA, which won the Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine in 2022, proved that Neanderthals are our ancestors, too. Today, people who descended from the population that left Africa still have faint remnants of Neanderthal ancestry in their genome — somewhere between 1 and 3 percent of their DNA. That includes genes involved in skin pigmentation, the immune response and even whether you’re a morning person.
The nature, duration and frequency of “admixture events” — when humans and Neanderthals paired up and had offspring — has long been unclear. The Science paper suggests these weren’t exceptional trysts but a way of life. Over a 7,000-year period beginning about 50,000 years ago, Neanderthals and humans had babies. For a large part of the modern-day population who trace their ancestry to the group that left Africa, 1 out of every 20 ancestors would have been a Neanderthal during this time period.
Genetics can’t reveal where this interbreeding happened, but many scientists speculate it occurred in the Middle East.
“Obviously, we cannot time travel, but this data is allowing us to time travel and see what’s happening 50,000 years ago in our history,” said Priya Moorjani, an assistant professor of molecular and cell biology at the University of California at Berkeley and a senior author of the study published in Science.
The study also underscores that our branch of humanity is just one of many on the family tree. The group of humans that left Africa didn’t depart as a monolithic group, with one prolonged multimillennia fling with Neanderthals. Some mingled with Neanderthals repeatedly but died out. Others arrived in Europe far earlier than the migration that led to present-day people but didn’t make it to the present.
A “cool thing is that we begin to see that the very first modern humans that came to Europe were divided into different populations, some of which mixed with Neandertals locally in Europe … and others that did not,” Svante Paabo, an evolutionary geneticist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, wrote in an email. Ancient DNA recovered from human remains in Romania and Bulgaria, for example, reveal humans who lived more than 40,000 years ago but had quite recent Neanderthal ancestors.
“Interesting also that none of these contributed their DNA to present-day people in Europe,” said Paabo, who was not involved in the new study.
The oldest modern human family
Beneath a castle in Ranis, Germany, an archaeological excavation in the 1930s unearthed ancient bone fragments and stone tools from more than 41,000 years ago. Archaeologists debated if these tools, from what’s called the Lincombian-Ranisian-Jerzmanowician culture, were made by humans or Neanderthals.
Drawing on a more recent excavation of the same site and by sifting painstakingly through dozens of boxes to find bone fragments that might have been misclassified as coming from other animals, researchers were able to gather enough DNA to reveal who this mystery population was. A research team led by scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology showed this year, using one kind of DNA, that they were humans who lived 45,000 years ago.
In the Nature paper, they were able to reconstruct their genomes. A mother and baby daughter, as well as another relative, were among a half-dozen individuals at the site. To their surprise, they also found that two of the Ranis individuals could have been distant cousins or great-great-great grandparents or children of a female whose skull was unearthed at Zlaty kun in the Czech Republic.
“Ranis is very exciting and gives us some sort of insight into the oldest modern human family that we have genetic data for,” said Arev P. Sümer, a computational biologist at Max Planck and the lead author of the Nature paper.
While these individuals are not related to modern-day people, they are a very close branch of the family tree. About 47,000 years ago, 80 generations before these people were born, their ancestors included Neanderthals — in the same interbreeding event that is a part of our history.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/science/2024/12/12/neanderthals-humans-interbreeding/?