Date: 8/05/2016 11:57:37
From: buffy
ID: 886594
Subject: NBN and fixed lines
I am feeling misled, and I’d like someone to tell me if I am being unreasonable. Last week we moved to NBN, with a bundle which included fixed line and all sorts of other things. We were given a new fixed line phone number and Mr buffy went to get the old number reinstated as we have had it for yonks. When this was done, the fixed line phone was disconnected and it seems now we only have VOIP through the NBN. This now means that when the power goes down, we no longer have a fixed line phone (as I understand it). And in this situation there is a high probability all phones/NBN will also be down. This is not what we understood to be what we were buying. I want a fixed line phone in place for emergencies. Am I being unreasonable?
I am thinking I’ll go to Telstra tomorrow and get the cheapest available copper phone number to keep in reserve. I am prepared to pay for it, because I think it is important, but I’m mightily pissed off that we were misled.
Date: 8/05/2016 11:59:17
From: Spiny Norman
ID: 886596
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
From what (little) I know, the system in the house has a battery back-up so you can still use the phone if the power goes out. The fibre line still have to be working, of course.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:00:09
From: roughbarked
ID: 886597
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
buffy said:
I am feeling misled, and I’d like someone to tell me if I am being unreasonable. Last week we moved to NBN, with a bundle which included fixed line and all sorts of other things. We were given a new fixed line phone number and Mr buffy went to get the old number reinstated as we have had it for yonks. When this was done, the fixed line phone was disconnected and it seems now we only have VOIP through the NBN. This now means that when the power goes down, we no longer have a fixed line phone (as I understand it). And in this situation there is a high probability all phones/NBN will also be down. This is not what we understood to be what we were buying. I want a fixed line phone in place for emergencies. Am I being unreasonable?
I am thinking I’ll go to Telstra tomorrow and get the cheapest available copper phone number to keep in reserve. I am prepared to pay for it, because I think it is important, but I’m mightily pissed off that we were misled.
They cut the copper off when the NBN arrives. There will be no going back.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:04:30
From: Tamb
ID: 886598
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
roughbarked said:
buffy said:
I am feeling misled, and I’d like someone to tell me if I am being unreasonable. Last week we moved to NBN, with a bundle which included fixed line and all sorts of other things. We were given a new fixed line phone number and Mr buffy went to get the old number reinstated as we have had it for yonks. When this was done, the fixed line phone was disconnected and it seems now we only have VOIP through the NBN. This now means that when the power goes down, we no longer have a fixed line phone (as I understand it). And in this situation there is a high probability all phones/NBN will also be down. This is not what we understood to be what we were buying. I want a fixed line phone in place for emergencies. Am I being unreasonable?
I am thinking I’ll go to Telstra tomorrow and get the cheapest available copper phone number to keep in reserve. I am prepared to pay for it, because I think it is important, but I’m mightily pissed off that we were misled.
They cut the copper off when the NBN arrives. There will be no going back.
The Telstra geniuses were running the air-con in the mobile stations off batteries when the power goes off. Naturally there was a rapid loss of service to mobiles.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:08:31
From: buffy
ID: 886601
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Spiny Norman said:
From what (little) I know, the system in the house has a battery back-up so you can still use the phone if the power goes out. The fibre line still have to be working, of course.
We are wireless, our aerial talks to the one up there on the mountain (points)
Date: 8/05/2016 12:10:19
From: buffy
ID: 886604
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
roughbarked said:
buffy said:
I am feeling misled, and I’d like someone to tell me if I am being unreasonable. Last week we moved to NBN, with a bundle which included fixed line and all sorts of other things. We were given a new fixed line phone number and Mr buffy went to get the old number reinstated as we have had it for yonks. When this was done, the fixed line phone was disconnected and it seems now we only have VOIP through the NBN. This now means that when the power goes down, we no longer have a fixed line phone (as I understand it). And in this situation there is a high probability all phones/NBN will also be down. This is not what we understood to be what we were buying. I want a fixed line phone in place for emergencies. Am I being unreasonable?
I am thinking I’ll go to Telstra tomorrow and get the cheapest available copper phone number to keep in reserve. I am prepared to pay for it, because I think it is important, but I’m mightily pissed off that we were misled.
They cut the copper off when the NBN arrives. There will be no going back.
Well, sort of. We are still a copper town. And the wires are still sitting out there in the street and under the house. And the exchange is still in place. So….as the town will unlikely be all NBN any time soon (some people have been put off for months for their installation) I reckon I should be able to reinstate a separate copper line. Which, of course, I will have to pay for.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:13:34
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886608
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Date: 8/05/2016 12:15:19
From: buffy
ID: 886610
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
We do have a generator and the house is wired to switch to generator power. But that won’t help much if the tower up the hill is down. On the copper system the phones just worked in a blackout.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:16:17
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886613
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
>>nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
incorrect.
I bought one off the shelf
Date: 8/05/2016 12:16:59
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886616
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Do you have two NBN boxes or one?
Date: 8/05/2016 12:24:52
From: nut
ID: 886622
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:26:44
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886624
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
CrazyNeutrino said:
Do you have two NBN boxes or one?
If you have one NBN box then you have no NBN battery
ring them up and ask for the battery backup to be fitted
now you have two options
one is to buy a battery modem router and use that when the power fails
or buy a relay and 12 volt battery for your modem and phone and set up the relay so it switches between the mains and the battery during a power failure
battery routers
https://www.google.com.au/search?q=battery+modem+router&source=univ&tbm=shop&tbo=u&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjj6vOGtsnMAhXGjZQKHWHsBGMQsxgIHA
http://www.ebay.com.au/sch/i.html?_nkw=battery+wifi+router&_fromfsb=0&_trksid=m270.l1313&LH_ItemCondition=1000&ul_noapp=true
Date: 8/05/2016 12:27:59
From: Tamb
ID: 886625
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
nut said:
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:29:47
From: roughbarked
ID: 886627
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
nut said:
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
Mine’s a 3.75.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:30:13
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886628
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
nut said:
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
I got a UPS. $150
will run 2 laptops and the dialysis machine for 8 hours.
completely plug and play
Date: 8/05/2016 12:31:34
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886630
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
nut said:
CrazyNeutrino said:
You will need two battery backups
one battery backup for the NBN Modem (if you have two NBN boxes, one is the battery)
you will then need a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
In my opinion they haven’t really let consumers know about the need for 2 battery backups
nor a there a simple off the shelve solution (yet) for getting a second battery backup for your own modem and phone
which requires a relay to switch between mains and battery backup when the power fails
a business opportunity for someone
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
most cheap ups only go for two minutes so get one that lasts at least an hour
you can add batteries in parallel to make them last longer
Date: 8/05/2016 12:35:03
From: Tamb
ID: 886632
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
roughbarked said:
Tamb said:
nut said:
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
Mine’s a 3.75.
Honda didn’t make one of those when I bought mine.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:35:55
From: Tamb
ID: 886633
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
stumpy_seahorse said:
Tamb said:
nut said:
Get a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). Many different options and prices.
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
I got a UPS. $150
will run 2 laptops and the dialysis machine for 8 hours.
completely plug and play
But not a fridge/freezer.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:40:57
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886635
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
heres a n ups which should give around an hour for laptop modem phone
http://www.jaycar.com.au/IT-Products/Connectivity/Power-Products/1500VA-900W-230VAC-LCD-Line-Interactive-UPS-with-USB/p/MP5207
You will still need the NBN backup battery to be fitted
Date: 8/05/2016 12:41:11
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886636
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
stumpy_seahorse said:
Tamb said:
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
I got a UPS. $150
will run 2 laptops and the dialysis machine for 8 hours.
completely plug and play
But not a fridge/freezer.
fridge/freezer isn’t important, you can get a few hours of cold without power if left unopened.
it would run it, just unsure for how long as I haven’t tested it
Date: 8/05/2016 12:43:50
From: roughbarked
ID: 886637
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
roughbarked said:
Tamb said:
I run a 3.5kva inverter generator when the power goes off. Good for the fridge/freezer, the lights, TV & the computer.
Mine’s a 3.75.
Honda didn’t make one of those when I bought mine.
Mine’s not a Honda.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:51:24
From: sibeen
ID: 886638
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
I hate to say I told you so, but “I told you so”.
This was one of my bugbears with the NBN when it was first mooted. The back-up for the phone goes from being a centrallised system provided by the supplier to one where the onus is on the consumer. Saying that, it should not be difficult for the back-up to be provided. I looked into this when it was first proposed and, from memory, all that is required is a 12 volt battery. No switching required, no UPS required. The system runs on 12 volts (OK, may be 24V, can’t remember) and the battery is direct connected.
The issue is that the batteries will be required to be changed ever few years, and most consumers won’t realise that it is required, so after a few years when the power fails so will their phone.
Date: 8/05/2016 12:58:38
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886641
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
yeah Im not really all that happy with the NBN VOIP solution
what would have been ideal is for the NBN battery box to have two 12 volt outputs one for the owners modem and one for the owners phone
then no need for an ups or battery router
Date: 8/05/2016 12:58:47
From: Ian
ID: 886642
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
buffy said:
We do have a generator and the house is wired to switch to generator power. But that won’t help much if the tower up the hill is down. On the copper system the phones just worked in a blackout.
The towers have their own battery backup.
It should be a simple matter to port your old landline number to your new voip setup.
BTW what sort of internet speed are you getting now?
Date: 8/05/2016 13:02:17
From: sibeen
ID: 886643
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
The Telstra geniuses were running the air-con in the mobile stations off batteries when the power goes off. Naturally there was a rapid loss of service to mobiles.
It does depend upon the installed infrastructure, but in many cases the air-con is required otherwise the equipment will shut down due to thermal constraints. So in many cases the air-con is required and this is taken into account when designing the battery autonomy required for a site.
Believe it or not but the Telco companies actually employ people who think about these things. Why, a few of them may have even shoved a few sheckels my way over the years.
Date: 8/05/2016 13:04:26
From: Ian
ID: 886645
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
sibeen said:
I hate to say I told you so, but “I told you so”.
This was one of my bugbears with the NBN when it was first mooted. The back-up for the phone goes from being a centrallised system provided by the supplier to one where the onus is on the consumer. Saying that, it should not be difficult for the back-up to be provided. I looked into this when it was first proposed and, from memory, all that is required is a 12 volt battery. No switching required, no UPS required. The system runs on 12 volts (OK, may be 24V, can’t remember) and the battery is direct connected.
The issue is that the batteries will be required to be changed ever few years, and most consumers won’t realise that it is required, so after a few years when the power fails so will their phone.
Should be ok.. the battery packs start beeping when they are running low.
Date: 8/05/2016 13:12:20
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886646
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
CrazyNeutrino said:
yeah Im not really all that happy with the NBN VOIP solution
what would have been ideal is for the NBN battery box to have two 12 volt outputs one for the owners modem and one for the owners phone
then no need for an ups or battery router
measure the wattage for the NBN modem
measure the wattage for the owners modem
measure the wattage for the owners phone
then work out if extra batteries are required
Date: 8/05/2016 13:39:52
From: Tamb
ID: 886647
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
stumpy_seahorse said:
Tamb said:
stumpy_seahorse said:
I got a UPS. $150
will run 2 laptops and the dialysis machine for 8 hours.
completely plug and play
But not a fridge/freezer.
fridge/freezer isn’t important, you can get a few hours of cold without power if left unopened.
it would run it, just unsure for how long as I haven’t tested it
We lost power for 2 weeks after Larry & 9 days after Yasi so fridge/freezer is pretty important to us.
Date: 8/05/2016 13:40:19
From: Tamb
ID: 886648
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
roughbarked said:
Tamb said:
roughbarked said:
Mine’s a 3.75.
Honda didn’t make one of those when I bought mine.
Mine’s not a Honda.
Well that would explain it.
Date: 8/05/2016 13:42:40
From: Tamb
ID: 886649
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
sibeen said:
Tamb said:
The Telstra geniuses were running the air-con in the mobile stations off batteries when the power goes off. Naturally there was a rapid loss of service to mobiles.
It does depend upon the installed infrastructure, but in many cases the air-con is required otherwise the equipment will shut down due to thermal constraints. So in many cases the air-con is required and this is taken into account when designing the battery autonomy required for a site.
Believe it or not but the Telco companies actually employ people who think about these things. Why, a few of them may have even shoved a few sheckels my way over the years.
Maybe for short, city type outages but as I said 2 weeks after Larry.
Date: 8/05/2016 13:45:00
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886650
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
stumpy_seahorse said:
Tamb said:
But not a fridge/freezer.
fridge/freezer isn’t important, you can get a few hours of cold without power if left unopened.
it would run it, just unsure for how long as I haven’t tested it
We lost power for 2 weeks after Larry & 9 days after Yasi so fridge/freezer is pretty important to us.
a UPS would be useless in that kind of situation.
At Joeys we had a light tower with a 3 cylinder diesel genset in it that we ran the whole site from after her fire
Date: 8/05/2016 13:52:08
From: wookiemeister
ID: 886651
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
the NBN install no longer has the battery back up option as standard – you have to ask for it for no extra cost to youv
Date: 8/05/2016 14:01:46
From: buffy
ID: 886653
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Ian said:
buffy said:
We do have a generator and the house is wired to switch to generator power. But that won’t help much if the tower up the hill is down. On the copper system the phones just worked in a blackout.
The towers have their own battery backup.
It should be a simple matter to port your old landline number to your new voip setup.
BTW what sort of internet speed are you getting now?
Hang on, I’‘ll do a speed check. Given I only really read you lot and the ABC news, I haven’t noticed a lot of difference. Except that uploading to Photobucket seems a hell of a lot faster.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:02:31
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886654
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
stumpy_seahorse said:
Tamb said:
stumpy_seahorse said:
fridge/freezer isn’t important, you can get a few hours of cold without power if left unopened.
it would run it, just unsure for how long as I haven’t tested it
We lost power for 2 weeks after Larry & 9 days after Yasi so fridge/freezer is pretty important to us.
a UPS would be useless in that kind of situation.
At Joeys we had a light tower with a 3 cylinder diesel genset in it that we ran the whole site from after her fire

Date: 8/05/2016 14:05:49
From: sibeen
ID: 886655
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
sibeen said:
Tamb said:
The Telstra geniuses were running the air-con in the mobile stations off batteries when the power goes off. Naturally there was a rapid loss of service to mobiles.
It does depend upon the installed infrastructure, but in many cases the air-con is required otherwise the equipment will shut down due to thermal constraints. So in many cases the air-con is required and this is taken into account when designing the battery autonomy required for a site.
Believe it or not but the Telco companies actually employ people who think about these things. Why, a few of them may have even shoved a few sheckels my way over the years.
Maybe for short, city type outages but as I said 2 weeks after Larry.
In those cases the site have an input for a mobile generator. There is no business in the world that is going to be installing a battery system for a two week outage.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:06:07
From: buffy
ID: 886656
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Here we go:

We used to be 5mps or 6mps if we were lucky, and 30kps upload – on a good day. So it is obviously better. But not that noticeable for what I do.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:10:03
From: stumpy_seahorse
ID: 886657
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
sibeen said:
Tamb said:
sibeen said:
It does depend upon the installed infrastructure, but in many cases the air-con is required otherwise the equipment will shut down due to thermal constraints. So in many cases the air-con is required and this is taken into account when designing the battery autonomy required for a site.
Believe it or not but the Telco companies actually employ people who think about these things. Why, a few of them may have even shoved a few sheckels my way over the years.
Maybe for short, city type outages but as I said 2 weeks after Larry.
In those cases the site have an input for a mobile generator. There is no business in the world that is going to be installing a battery system for a two week outage.
I was talking to my cousin’s partner a couple of months ago and fr a while his job was to 4×4 out to telstra’s mobile towers and plug i a generator on a trailer.
They’d call him, send through a GPS coordinate and he’d have to find the tower, get to it and sit there until they had the power back on to it.
reckons it was the cruisiest job he ever had
Date: 8/05/2016 14:10:26
From: transition
ID: 886658
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
You could buy the Port Augusta power station, buffy
I know, helpful
I’m reading the thread and working on the proportions of your dilemma
Date: 8/05/2016 14:14:23
From: buffy
ID: 886659
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
transition said:
You could buy the Port Augusta power station, buffy
I know, helpful
I’m reading the thread and working on the proportions of your dilemma
I’d need a long extension lead…..
:)
Date: 8/05/2016 14:16:11
From: Ian
ID: 886660
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
buffy said:
Here we go:
!http://www.speedtest.net/result/5308793189.png
We used to be 5mps or 6mps if we were lucky, and 30kps upload – on a good day. So it is obviously better. But not that noticeable for what I do.
Sounds good thanks.
We’ve got a new tower about to go live less than 2 Km away. It’ll be interesting to see how good the signal is after passing through quite a lot of tree tops.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:24:01
From: The Rev Dodgson
ID: 886663
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Apparently the NBN should be available in my area within 3 years.
And generously Telstra will allow me to sign up to one of their plans now, so I’m ready when it arrives.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:25:12
From: buffy
ID: 886664
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Ian said:
buffy said:
Here we go:
!http://www.speedtest.net/result/5308793189.png
We used to be 5mps or 6mps if we were lucky, and 30kps upload – on a good day. So it is obviously better. But not that noticeable for what I do.
Sounds good thanks.
We’ve got a new tower about to go live less than 2 Km away. It’ll be interesting to see how good the signal is after passing through quite a lot of tree tops.
Our tower is about 1km line of sight up on Mt Rouse. We have mature gums in our backyard, which we actually thought might be a problem, but apparently are not.
Date: 8/05/2016 14:51:59
From: transition
ID: 886667
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
here we’re wireless, it’s good, thanx to telstra looking after country people.
speeds always excellent, service is reliable, tower’s only about 400metres away atop the silos, signal strength is 100% inside a triple lined faraday cage, which is about what the work sheds here are, colourbond outside, overlapped taped aircell, then colourbond on the inside.
previous out the farm we was fringe ~6km over a few hills, you’d have to put the computer in the right spot in the house, and it seemed to use a lot of data, correcting errors I suppose
our ups here’s 8 x deep cycle batteries. No mains power or landline services
haven’t had a blackout for ~ six years.
Date: 8/05/2016 20:20:37
From: buffy
ID: 886859
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
This got me looking and I found the RMIT report on the Warrnambool Exchange Fire. It’s Quite Interesting. I see setting up the ‘spare’ routing to South Melbourne wasn’t done until about 2 years after. And the conclusion basically says there should be redundancies in the system that can be brought into play if/when needed. If anyone is interested:
http://telsoc.org/ajtde/2014-12-v2-n4/a72
Date: 8/05/2016 21:07:30
From: sibeen
ID: 886872
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
buffy said:
This got me looking and I found the RMIT report on the Warrnambool Exchange Fire. It’s Quite Interesting. I see setting up the ‘spare’ routing to South Melbourne wasn’t done until about 2 years after. And the conclusion basically says there should be redundancies in the system that can be brought into play if/when needed. If anyone is interested:
http://telsoc.org/ajtde/2014-12-v2-n4/a72
The South Melbourne TE is the one I mentioned last week.
Date: 8/05/2016 21:12:45
From: Bubblecar
ID: 886873
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
And here she is, settling a little before the carve. There’s a rich garlic, mushroom, butter & wine sauce to accompany her, + peas.

Date: 8/05/2016 21:13:26
From: Bubblecar
ID: 886875
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
But you don’t get a roast bird with your NBN, sorry.
Date: 8/05/2016 22:20:56
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886897
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Date: 8/05/2016 22:23:31
From: CrazyNeutrino
ID: 886898
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Date: 8/05/2016 22:24:01
From: buffy
ID: 886899
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
sibeen said:
buffy said:
This got me looking and I found the RMIT report on the Warrnambool Exchange Fire. It’s Quite Interesting. I see setting up the ‘spare’ routing to South Melbourne wasn’t done until about 2 years after. And the conclusion basically says there should be redundancies in the system that can be brought into play if/when needed. If anyone is interested:
http://telsoc.org/ajtde/2014-12-v2-n4/a72
The South Melbourne TE is the one I mentioned last week.
So does that mean we are safe now?
;)
Date: 9/05/2016 12:41:01
From: Rule 303
ID: 887086
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Buffy, there’s a range of alternatives to fixed line phones that can be employed in emergencies. Mobiles, radios, sat-phones, visual devices, personal alarm/duress devices, EPIRB devices and so on that will likely be more reliable, more portable, and often cheaper than having the old copper landline reinstated.
I’ve been in emergencies where everything but satellite failed.
Lateral thinking is your friend…
Date: 9/05/2016 12:43:24
From: dv
ID: 887093
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Date: 9/05/2016 12:44:06
From: Peak Warming Man
ID: 887095
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
dv said:
pigeons
Speckled Jim.
Date: 9/05/2016 12:47:28
From: Rule 303
ID: 887100
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
dv said:
pigeons
Could be faster than my new internet connection – Iprimus are on Telstra hardware and Telstra wont release any more ADSL2+ ports at the local exchange.
Fuckers…
Date: 9/05/2016 12:48:33
From: dv
ID: 887102
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
dv said:
pigeons
Could be faster than my new internet connection – Iprimus are on Telstra hardware and Telstra wont release any more ADSL2+ ports at the local exchange.
Fuckers…
The breakup and sale of Telstra was a total shemozzle. Fuckin’ Labor.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:06:16
From: Rule 303
ID: 887105
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:11:18
From: poikilotherm
ID: 887107
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
I love my EPIRB, it’s like a Volvo, you feel safe doing stupid things ;)
Date: 9/05/2016 13:11:45
From: Tamb
ID: 887109
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
They don’t work in the rainforest. Neither does Satnav.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:13:32
From: Rule 303
ID: 887111
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
They don’t work in the rainforest. Neither does Satnav.
Not too much rainforest in SW Victoria.
;-)
Date: 9/05/2016 13:14:53
From: Tamb
ID: 887114
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
Tamb said:
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
They don’t work in the rainforest. Neither does Satnav.
Not too much rainforest in SW Victoria.
;-)
No you blokes manage to burn it all.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:19:29
From: dv
ID: 887116
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:21:54
From: ChrispenEvan
ID: 887117
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Not too much rainforest in SW Victoria.
yeah, there is. not tropical rainforest but temperate rainporest. mountain ash country.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rainforest_in_Victoria_(Australia)
Date: 9/05/2016 13:22:13
From: ChrispenEvan
ID: 887118
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Date: 9/05/2016 13:23:34
From: Rule 303
ID: 887120
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
dv said:
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
Seems hit-and-miss.
EPIRB works by both transmission to Sat and line of site, IIRC.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:23:44
From: bob(from black rock)
ID: 887121
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
poikilotherm said:
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
I love my EPIRB, it’s like a Volvo, you feel safe doing stupid things ;)
And buying a Volvo is doing a stupid thing?
Date: 9/05/2016 13:23:47
From: Tamb
ID: 887122
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
dv said:
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
I’ve seen it not work. If it can’t see the satellites it won’t work.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:27:46
From: Peak Warming Man
ID: 887124
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
dv said:
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
Seems hit-and-miss.
EPIRB works by both transmission to Sat and line of site, IIRC.
I think satnave might have improved but the last time I tried to use a satnav device up on the heavily forested McPherson ranges it couldn’t get a fix.
That was 8 or 9 years ago though.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:36:33
From: dv
ID: 887127
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Tamb said:
dv said:
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
I’ve seen it not work. If it can’t see the satellites it won’t work.
Well it only needs to “see” them at 1 GHz (30 centimetre band), not in visible light.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:40:36
From: ChrispenEvan
ID: 887128
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
can be a lot of attenuation in a forest.
Date: 9/05/2016 13:43:14
From: Tamb
ID: 887129
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
dv said:
Tamb said:
dv said:
I don’t agree that Satnav doesn’t work in a rainforest.
I’ve seen it not work. If it can’t see the satellites it won’t work.
Well it only needs to “see” them at 1 GHz (30 centimetre band), not in visible light.
When is say see I don’t mean visible light.
It needs at least two to get a fix & we are not well served by satellites here at 17° South.
In open country we can get 4 but even at my home I can’t get more than 2. The basalt hills knock out most signals which is why we use
VHF radios not
UHF.
Date: 9/05/2016 17:12:39
From: buffy
ID: 887214
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Rule 303 said:
An EPIRB, for example, which will transmit a distress signal including its location to emergency services and will work almost anywhere on Earth, costs about the same as 10 months of home phone line and network charges.
But we know where we are. This is a house…. I want to be able to ring out if necessary if the power is off.
Anyway, I went to Telstra this morning and told them that I am unhappy that we were not informed of the lack of phone in a power outage, and that a fax machine will not work on the new system. I have chosen to reinstate the copper line, as well as keeping the new system going. It will cost me around $25 per month to do this. I think it is worthwhile, and they can tell me when they rip the stuff out. I doubt very much that will be within 5 years or so.
Date: 9/05/2016 18:07:31
From: fsm
ID: 887238
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
Bubblecar said:
And here she is, settling a little before the carve. There’s a rich garlic, mushroom, butter & wine sauce to accompany her, + peas.

Must be a backup battery hen…
Date: 9/05/2016 18:09:47
From: Michael V
ID: 887239
Subject: re: NBN and fixed lines
fsm said:
Bubblecar said:
And here she is, settling a little before the carve. There’s a rich garlic, mushroom, butter & wine sauce to accompany her, + peas.

Must be a backup battery hen…
snigger