Date: 10/05/2016 11:57:49
From: dv
ID: 887514
Subject:

This is 3 years old but I did not see it at the time.
I confess, I wrote the Arsenic DNA paper to expose flaws in peer-review at subscription based journals – See more at: http://www.michaeleisen.org/blog/?p=1439#sthash.lU1YRyHx.dpuf


In 2011, after having read several really bad papers in the journal Science, I decided to explore just how slipshod their peer-review process is. I knew that their business depends on publishing “sexy” papers. So I created a manuscript that claimed something extraordinary – that I’d discovered a species of bacteria that uses arsenic in its DNA instead of phosphorus. But I made the science so egregiously bad that no competent peer reviewer would accept it. The approach was deeply flawed – there were poor or absent controls in every figure. I used ludicrously elaborate experiments where simple ones would have done. And I failed to include a simple, obvious experiment that would have definitively shown that arsenic was really in the bacteria’s DNA. I then submitted the paper to Science, punching up the impact the work would have on our understanding of extraterrestrials and the origins of life on Earth in the cover letter. And what do you know? They accepted it!

Reply Quote

Date: 19/07/2016 18:51:39
From: SCIENCE
ID: 927307
Subject: re:

¿something comparable?

NRPC takes the best students in Year 7 (and continues to poach students from other schools). Over the next 6 years they suffer a sustained assault on their intelligence, leaching value from the students and turning leaders into slaves. Students are intensely vocal about perceived social issues that are highly visible, but find it far too difficult to look at themselves to recognise the failure of their own education.

As a school where students routinely outperform the rest of the state in the HSC, it has increasingly attracted students and caregivers whose sole concern has been exactly that. It was once a school that brought the best teachers and students together, enabling them to work together to achieve the highest academic results. Now it brings stressed, ATAR-obsessed students and pathetic, cowardly teachers together, to wreck the education of a whole generation of academically gifted students by screwing up their school. Teachers could not carry out this disastrous campaign without the support of students and caregivers, even if that support is not through action, but inaction.

http://nrpc.byethost10.com/nrpc.pdf

Reply Quote