wookiemeister said:
Can you communicate with a vehicle so far away?
I (in common with many science fiction writers, I must say), initially thought that communication fast enough to send TV images from the Moon was impossible. Had a lot of egg on face over that one. Ditto I was shocked at how little power was required to send data back from Mars.
By Pluto, what was recorded by New Horizons in one day will have taken three months or so to send back.
Having been twice bitten, I’m somewhat shy about commenting. One thing that is exceedingly clear is that it’s far easier to communicate over interstellar distances than to travel interstellar distances. In communication you only have to send photons, which weigh considerably less than spacecraft. So communication is only going to be a relatively small problem. Also, the communications time lag of 8.5 years round trip is negligible compared to the spacecraft travel time.
Lets’s consider Proxima, and see what is necessary for communication. What is necessary is:
Sending power
Receiving dish size
Error correction codes
Focus
Avoidance of interference.
The sending power for New Horizons is 12 watts. An interstellar spacecraft could have nuclear reactors like those on a nuclear submarine, which generate 2.8 megawatts.
The focus angle of the New Horizons high gain communicator is 0.3 degrees. The focus angle of a laser communicator is 0.000003 degrees.
The receiving dish is for New horizons is 70 metres in diameter. Making that 700 metres in diameter is easily possible within the timeframe of spacecraft travel to Proxima.
Shannon limit error correction codes are getting better. I’m not sure how close to the limit they’ve already reached.
Interference is another topic. Let’s assume that some bright spark has figured out how to avoid interference, for example by using a UVC laser of Xaser or by positioning the spacecraft in front of an empty region of space.
So the distance we can communicate over is about (2.8e6/12)*(0.3/0.000003)*(700/70) times the distance to Pluto. That’s 230 billion times the distance to Pluto. Let’s say the distance to Pluto is 0.0005 light years.
So with (almost) current technology, a spacecraft could communicate with the Earth over a distance of 100 million light years. That’s not just interstellar distances, that intergalactic distances. The Large Magellanic Cloud is 158 thousand light years away.
Communication is not a significant problem.