Date: 6/09/2026 11:03:40
From: ms spock
ID: 2427205
Subject: re: Environment 2026

SCIENCE said:


ms spock said:

SCIENCE said:

speaking of

Project delivery lead Caine Mertens told the ABC the highly treated wastewater would be cleaner than the current river water and would improve local water quality. “The facility will treat wastewater to an advanced standard using reverse osmosis before releasing,” he said.

Ian Wright is a former Sydney Water scientist who spent 18 years with the company, and is now an associate professor and water science researcher at Western Sydney University. He said treating raw effluent reliably was difficult, and expressed concern with the proposal. “To put treated water, treated from sewage, into the Parramatta River is actually unbelievable to me,” Professor Wright said.

Local resident Andrew Yeung shared his concerns, given the area’s high recreational use. “We’ve got swimming areas, three downstream, and a junior sailing club, as well as three boat ramps,” he said. “We’re very concerned about potential for a combination of factors heading over a tipping point and creating an environmental disaster.

so is it going to be reverse osmosed or not

because if that’s an honest representation then how is it going to be worse

How sure can you be that is an honest representation?

Some one who is in a vital position could leave and the water quality could drop.

hence the if

also Sydney is pretty disgusting so it’sn’t hard for treated water to improve the quality

but you’re right, Australians want coal burning fascists so we’re doubtful it’ll be continued improvement

That’s black and white thinking.

Just because you want details of what is proposed. Or have questions about how quality control will be maintained does not mean Australians want coal burning fascists to continue.

It just means folks have questions about what is involved.

How will quality be maintained?

What are the potential downsides?

For those who don’t understand the processes involved, how can they access the information?

If things go wrong how would that look like to those living close by?

If there are huge advantages how will that look like to those living close by?

If you understand how important this particular proposal why don’t you explain it?

We need to get rid of the coal burning fascists. A lack of knowledge (for some) has resulted in our current situation. Surely questions and engagement is to be encouraged?

Your base knowledge is not everyone else’s base knowledge.

Some research of which individuals and companies are involved and how much profit they stand to make might be warranted as well.

Questions don’t mean that folks are automatically rejecting a proposal. It means they are asking questions.

Having lived without a kitchen, a laundry in a caravan for almost a year (losing 90% my stuff) for almost a year due to extreme weather events. I am pretty keen to see the coal burning fascists lose.

But I don’t have to not ask questions or query for things to improve. I thought the opposite would be true.

Reply Quote View full thread