Divine Angel said:
The Rev Dodgson said:
Divine Angel said:I was always good at pure maths at school and would get 98 per cent in exams and an A* at A level. But when I got to university, I had to do something called abstract maths and I just couldn’t do it. I got 2 per cent in one exam. They would ask you to do things like prove that 1 is greater than 0. I couldn’t think or imagine how to do it. I’m great with maths when there is a formula, a structured problem to solve, all straight lines and black and white. But abstract maths – no thanks! I dropped the maths degree at the end of the first year.Powell, T. (2021). Processing information: Cognition, language and sensory issues. Recognising Autism and Asperger’s Syndrome: A Practical Guide to Adult Diagnosis and Beyond (2nd ed., pp. 83-104). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780367854904-ch05
Without resorting to fancy formulas, I can hold one of a thing in my hand, and I can’t hold nothing of a thing in my other hand.
I’m not a lover of abstract maths either, but I thought 1 was defined as the integer after 0, so why does 1 being > 0 require a proof?
Just off the top of my head:
Depending on the branch of mathematics, 1 is defined by several core properties:🔢 Arithmetic & AlgebraMultiplicative Identity: Any number multiplied by 1 remains unchanged (\(a \times 1 = a\)).Division Property: Any number divided by 1 remains itself (\(a \div 1 = a\)). Conversely, any non-zero number divided by itself equals 1 (\(a \div a = 1\)).Exponents: Any number raised to the power of 1 is itself (\(a^1 = a\)). Any non-zero number raised to the power of 0 is 1 (\(a^0 = 1\)).🧩 Number TheoryNeither Prime nor Composite: 1 is excluded from prime numbers because a prime must have exactly two distinct positive divisors (1 and itself). 1 only has one divisor (itself).The Generator: In the set of integers, every number can be reached by repeatedly adding or subtracting 1.📐 Set Theory & FoundationsThe Successor of Zero: In the Peano axioms (which define the natural numbers), 1 is formally defined as the successor of 0, written as \(S(0)\).Cardonality: It represents the size (cardinality) of a set that contains exactly one element, such as the set \(\{\emptyset\}\).
Deep.