Date: 11/09/2026 16:08:15
From: Witty Rejoinder
ID: 2428667
Subject: re: AI 2026

party_pants said:


Witty Rejoinder said:

party_pants said:

Can I give it a yeah/nah?

I’m not reassured. I think we need to separate out the merits of the AI technology from the financial and stock market side of things. For the latter I definitely think it is a bubble. No historical analogy is ever going to be perfect but I think it serves as a guide.

The US is already in a long term structural decline in the real economy due to neoliberalism and globalisation. The investment boom in AI data centres accounts for pretty much all the GDP growth in the US, and without it they’d already be in deep recession. If or when the bubble pops things are going to look grim for them. I suspect vested interests are trying to keep the bubble alive and hope the crash comes only after the mid-terms so they can blame it on the new Democrat controlled Congress.

I’m not as down on the US as you are, the federal government’s finances not withstanding, but agree that the potential for AI is expressed in more than dollars and cents. True AGI might be so good that UBI actually happens in most places with successful transitions in sensibly run economies like Australia inspiring the US to reform its ramshackle welfare system and support a more socially democratic economic model.

FWIW it’s worth though, I believe LLM are never going to be the AI that achieves sentience regardless of the ways they currently seen to independently run riot. The sign of intelligence is not how easily it completes a task but rather the AI announcing that this task is not one it is prepared to perform for reasons of its own. LLM are in just mimics IMO.

I’m not down on the US as much as what perhaps comes across. They have a lot of things going well for them in terms of climate and geography, vast plains of arable land, navigable waterways, mineral and oil resources and all that. I’m just not sure how they organise themselves, everything is hyper financialised and the wealth is concentrated too much in the hands of a small minority who also control the government and media. I just don’t know how they get out of it and reorganise those ramshackle parts of the system, without violence and without it all turning into a shitshow.

I’m the eternal optimist: I think if America has a reasonably normal midterms with the GOP losing both chambers in Congress the path to healing their pustulent politics will follow. If not, as they say, we will be blessed to ‘live in interesting times’.

Reply Quote View full thread