The Rev Dodgson said:
Michael V said:
JudgeMental said:
Carrick Ryanabout an hour ago
At some point in the last 20 years, national pride became a truly divisive political issue, and it’s worth examining why… because as simple as it might be to blame this all on the rise of the far right, there’s far more to this story.
I’ve made my position clear a few times now that I find the notion of “national pride” a bit silly, just as I find the notion of collective national shame for historical crimes overwhelmingly illogical.
I have raised my concerns about how national pride becomes dangerous when it is weaponised by nationalists with more sinister objectives. But I also think that it is, for the most part, fairly harmless when left unexploited by political operatives.
We all have an inherent desire to belong to a collective, and to share in each other’s achievements. It’s why I wear the jerseys of my favourite sporting team and cheer “our” victories, as though my supportive screams from my living room somehow contributed to the outcome.
But at some point, this otherwise harmless joy from being part of the unparalleled success story that is the Australian project took on a more menacing and nefarious hostility.
When tracking this evolution through News Corp narratives and social media algorithms, it’s also prudent to ask how progressive discourse might have, at the very least, hastened this radicalisation. If we are to critically examine the more toxic elements of progressive politics over the past 20 years, it is the proclivity towards puritanism that must bear some responsibility for our societal polarisation. These are the doctrines that denounced anyone who failed to align with the values of progressive orthodoxy as not just wrong, but fundamentally immoral.
In fairness, the race riots of Cronulla in 2005 no doubt fermented the correlation between our national flag and violence in the minds of many, but the extent to which this was extrapolated and fermented to condemn any Australian who found joy in their national identity created an atmosphere akin to a cultural revolution, possessed by a perceived moral urgency.
This manifested itself most prominently in the Australia Day debate. Not because the “change the date” campaign was wrong in their objectives, but because the campaign made little attempt to change the minds of those who enjoyed the national holiday for entirely innocent reasons, and instead focused on the moral condemnation of those who failed to appreciate the way their joy was experienced by others. It has been, in many ways, Australia’s “basket of deplorables” moment.
Of course, this was not the only example of moral absolutism that has defined the last two decades. If anyone did not agree that Australia was racist, they themselves were cast as racist. If anyone raised concerns about the the propagation of Islamic fundamentalism, they were Islamaphobic. If anyone did not accept that gender identity was changeable, they were transphobic.
Gradually, many on the Left felt sufficiently empowered that they believed they were no longer compelled to explain the virtues of their position, and instead argued as though the righteousness of their position was a moral fact.
What we are witnessing across the MAGA’sphere and its proxies is the embrace of moral condemnation; a collective bravery to defy what they perceive to be cultural norms imposed by a social elite concerned more with ideological virtue signalling than practical outcomes.By demanding the moral orthodoxy of the Left be embraced in its totality to be tolerated at all, the moral absolutists created terms of compliance which were, essentially, “all or nothing”. Once the political power of the left waned, the latter option became increasingly viable.
It is within this environment that genuine moral depravity can proliferate unchecked, given free reign in an ecosystem that has deliberately absolved itself of the ethical guidelines that had defined how we think, speak, and act, in public and in private for decades. Once established and normalised, this new ecosystem celebrated the defiance of left-wing moral outrage, and no one could trigger this outrage like Donald Trump, or in Australia, Pauline Hanson.
This is the fertile ground in which the truly sinister political aspirants can emerge within a rising tide of moral outcasts, insisting that even the most objectively degenerate beliefs were yet another example of common sense maligned by left-wing elites.
But while Australian flags at barbecues on Australia Day caused me no alarm, the sight of the same flags at rallies and protests are, in my eyes, evidence of their usurpation by a social movement which seeks to take ownership of the symbol; a proclamation of a political allegiance which assigns our national flag to their specific idea of Australia. This is a claim that many on the Left helped reinforce.
My objective here is not to castigate those who, in almost every instance, were seeking to create a more inclusive and empathetic society. But I am hopeful that if we can achieve the necessary self-awareness to acknowledge how good intentions might have helped create this problem, it could offer us clues to the solution.
The political left has squandered its era of political power through over reach and inflexibility. It’s opportunity to return to power lies in the fact the political right seems committed to making the exact same mistakes. If these seemingly unstoppable populist movements are to be sidelined, the political centre must present itself more loudly as a viable option, one more forgiving of moral disagreements that need not decide elections.
It’s often said that it’s lonely place to be a centrist, but there are no shortages of those looking for an off ramp inbetween the escalating political fringes. What’s needed is louder voices, assuring them that they aren’t alone after all.
Fair comment. I think that is part, but not all of it. There is also some anti-intellectualism mixed in there too. (And maybe some other stuff as well.)
Didn’t seem fair to me.
Seems rather an attempt to blame “the left” for the goings on of “the right”.
Which is the standard fare.