A 2014 study published in Cognitive Science found what many developmental psychologists have long suspected: children exposed to religion were significantly less able to distinguish between real and fantastical characters. When presented with stories, religious children identified religious figures as real, but also struggled to correctly identify fictional characters as fictional compared to their secular peers.
This is not about intelligence. It is about epistemology — how we teach children to know what is true.
By Religion: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
🔬 WHAT THE EVIDENCE ACTUALLY SAYS
Developmental research is clear on two points:
Children are natural credulity machines. Work by Harris & Koenig (2006) shows children initially trust testimony over evidence, especially from trusted adults. That is adaptive for survival, but it makes them vulnerable.
Testimony matters. Corriveau, Chen & Harris (2015) demonstrated that 5-6 year old children in religious schools were more likely to judge characters from both religious and fantastical stories as real, compared to secular-schooled peers who showed much stronger reality monitoring.
The mechanism is not mysterious. If a child is taught that an invisible, omnipotent being watches them, answers prayers, and can suspend the laws of physics, the boundary between verifiable fact and authoritative claim is systematically weakened. The child learns that truth comes from authority and repetition, not from evidence and falsifiability. #EvidenceBased
We do not teach children that 2+2=5 because it feels comforting. We should not teach them that faith — belief without evidence — is a virtue, while simultaneously expecting them to excel at science.
🤔 WHY THIS MATTERS FOR EVERYONE
A democracy and a modern economy depend on reality-based decision making. Public health, climate change, misinformation, conspiracy theories — all require the same cognitive muscle: the ability to ask, “What is the evidence? How could I be wrong?”
When we normalize believing extraordinary claims without extraordinary evidence in one domain, we train that muscle to atrophy in all domains. That is the cost.
Questions for the reader:
If we would not accept “because I feel it is true” as an answer in a courtroom or a laboratory, why do we celebrate it in a church, mosque, or temple?
What is the ethical difference between teaching a child a false history fact versus a false metaphysical fact?
Are we protecting children, or protecting an idea from scrutiny by giving it to children before they can scrutinize it?
🛠️ RECOMMENDATIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT: A SECULAR TOOLKIT
We do not need to be hostile to improve. We need to be honest.
1. For Parents and Families: Replace faith-based answers with inquiry-based answers. Instead of “because God made it that way,” try “I don’t know, let’s find out how we could know.” Normalize saying “I don’t know” — it is more truthful than false certainty. #RaiseThinkers
2. For Educators: Teach epistemology early. Age-appropriate lessons on the difference between a claim, a belief, and evidence. Comparative religion should be taught as literature and culture, not as competing truth claims. Teach the scientific method as a lived practice, not just a poster on the wall.
3. For All of Us: Defend secular public education. Support policies that keep proselytizing out of public classrooms while keeping critical thinking in. Contribute by funding libraries, science museums, and after-school programs that teach skepticism and media literacy. Challenge your own sacred cows with the same sharpness you challenge others’.
The goal is not to make children cynical. The goal is to make them discerning. A child who can tell fact from fiction is not a lesser child — she is a freer one.
📖 REFERENCES
Corriveau, K. H., Chen, E. E., & Harris, P. L. (2015). Judgments about fact and fiction by children from religious and nonreligious backgrounds. *Cognitive Science, 39*(2), 353-382.
Harris, P. L., & Koenig, M. A. (2006). Trust in testimony: How children learn about science and religion. *Child Development, 77*(3), 505-524.