Date: 19/10/2026 12:45:38
From: Spiny Norman
ID: 2440359
Subject: re: Old Photos 2

captain_spalding said:


Cymek said:

captain_spalding said:

I don’t think that most people realise just how big those things were, or of their capabilities and the work that went into them.

There’s a very good book about it, ‘Chariots for Apollo: A History of Manned Lunar Spacecraft’ which came out in 1979. So many ‘firsts’ went into their development which is not really surprising. Quite notable was the striving for reliability, which may have been one reason why the Grumman ‘ironworks’ got the job.

Do you simplicity works for space flight.
Do modern computers, electronics complicated the procedure and slow it down.
Less risk taking obviously slows it down which I imagine during the Apollo missions was still important to reduce risk but causalities was acceptable

I think that Spiny would be the one to comment here. Perhaps his experience in moving up through progressively larger and more technological aircraft would throw some relevant light on the question.

The Apollo programme avoided cutting-edge gear where possible and tried to stick with know & very reliable gear as much as they could. Naturally a bunch of brand-new techniques & technology had to be created and a lot of the Gemini programme was used to test all that. And they learned from it.
There were a number of things that presented substantial obstacles and took a huge amount of effort and work to get under control.
The first stage Rocketdyne F1 engines. It took them a year or so to get the combustion chamber instability worked out. They very nearly didn’t.
It also took a long time to get the second stage down to an acceptable weight. For example they had to get creative when welding the ends of the oyxgen & fuel tanks on as using regular welding just didn’t work. Too much distortion and so potential weak sports.
So they just used hundreds of clamps to hold them together and removed one when they needed to weld under it. Then put the clamp back and repeat a few hundred more times.
The LM also had weight problems but the Grumman team just kept on working hard on it and got it very right.

Reply Quote View full thread