Date: 19/10/2026 18:16:58
From: Cymek
ID: 2440463
Subject: re: Old Photos 2

Spiny Norman said:


Ian said:

Spiny Norman said:

The Apollo programme avoided cutting-edge gear where possible and tried to stick with know & very reliable gear as much as they could. Naturally a bunch of brand-new techniques & technology had to be created and a lot of the Gemini programme was used to test all that. And they learned from it.
There were a number of things that presented substantial obstacles and took a huge amount of effort and work to get under control.
The first stage Rocketdyne F1 engines. It took them a year or so to get the combustion chamber instability worked out. They very nearly didn’t.
It also took a long time to get the second stage down to an acceptable weight. For example they had to get creative when welding the ends of the oyxgen & fuel tanks on as using regular welding just didn’t work. Too much distortion and so potential weak sports.
So they just used hundreds of clamps to hold them together and removed one when they needed to weld under it. Then put the clamp back and repeat a few hundred more times.
The LM also had weight problems but the Grumman team just kept on working hard on it and got it very right.

I was watching some vids recently about the LEM ascent stage..

The ascent propulsion system (APS) or lunar module ascent engine (LMAE) is a fixed-thrust hypergolic (rocket propellant whose components spontaneously ignite upon contact) rocket engine developed by Bell Aerosystems for use in the Apollo Lunar Module ascent stage. It used Aerozine 50 fuel, and N2O4 oxidizer.

It had to work first time and was never tested whole on the ground.

True, the flight engine was not tested but they tested quite a lot of them to make sure it’d work every time. All it had was two valves that opened to let the fuel & oxidiser flow – under pressure from a pressurised helium bottle so no pumps – and it absolutely start every time. Not able to be throttled nor gimballed like the descent engine.
I remember reading that when they had a new batch of tanks (not sure which ones) they all tested just fine but one was a slightly different colour after the heat treating so they didn’t use it. The slightly different colour was enough of an eyeball test to reject it.

Does spaceflight need to have complex tech
Science fiction tends to tell us yes but in reality what would a spacecraft require for interplanetary or interstellar travel
Would we better off with analogue type switches instead of digital for example.

Reply Quote View full thread