Spiny Norman said:
Cymek said:
Spiny Norman said:True, the flight engine was not tested but they tested quite a lot of them to make sure it’d work every time. All it had was two valves that opened to let the fuel & oxidiser flow – under pressure from a pressurised helium bottle so no pumps – and it absolutely start every time. Not able to be throttled nor gimballed like the descent engine.
I remember reading that when they had a new batch of tanks (not sure which ones) they all tested just fine but one was a slightly different colour after the heat treating so they didn’t use it. The slightly different colour was enough of an eyeball test to reject it.Does spaceflight need to have complex tech
Science fiction tends to tell us yes but in reality what would a spacecraft require for interplanetary or interstellar travel
Would we better off with analogue type switches instead of digital for example.Yes & no.
Stuff that has to be extremely reliable has to be controlled by something that’s also extremely reliable. One of the problems with modern computers in space is the cosmic radiation hitting the cpu, ram, etc. It can very easily flip a bunch of bits to zero instead of one and that of course can lead to disaster.
I think the important gear is hardened as much as they reasonably can against that radiation and they also use multiple computers physically placed apart to reduce the chances of a couple getting zapped. I think the Space Shuttle had five main computers because of that.
Perhaps ironically, the older cpu’s & gear survived radiation better as the transistors were quite a lot larger and with bigger gaps between them, thus reducing the chances of computational & data corruption.The various mechanisms (probably) haven’t changed a great deal in the last half century or so. But the rocket power cycle has thanks to the ability to 3D print pretty much all of the engine. It has allowed the modern engines to run what’s called a full-flow staged cycle.
To save me writing it all out and no doubt making a mistake, check out this linkI imagine modern touch screen would be pretty reliable and would also allow you to quickly flick between systems when needed. So if there’s, say, four screens with one for each crew member if one fails three is more than enough to keep going safely.
Thanks