Date: 19/10/2026 18:58:13
From: Spiny Norman
ID: 2440487
Subject: re: Old Photos 2

captain_spalding said:


Cymek said:

Spiny Norman said:

True, the flight engine was not tested but they tested quite a lot of them to make sure it’d work every time. All it had was two valves that opened to let the fuel & oxidiser flow – under pressure from a pressurised helium bottle so no pumps – and it absolutely start every time. Not able to be throttled nor gimballed like the descent engine.
I remember reading that when they had a new batch of tanks (not sure which ones) they all tested just fine but one was a slightly different colour after the heat treating so they didn’t use it. The slightly different colour was enough of an eyeball test to reject it.

Does spaceflight need to have complex tech
Science fiction tends to tell us yes but in reality what would a spacecraft require for interplanetary or interstellar travel
Would we better off with analogue type switches instead of digital for example.

“…what would a spacecraft require for interplanetary or interstellar travel”

A honking big engine that you could use to accelerate you constantly for half of the journey, and some equally effective mechanism that you could use to slow yourself down for the second half of the journey.

Ah yeah I missed that sorry.
Interstellar travel is a couple of quantum levels more difficult. With current technology getting to the nearest star is going to take a good 50 years. (The old Project Orion still has vastly more performance than anything conceived after it)
So imagine that you have to have a group of people that’ll likely be dead before the end of the trip and they all have to live in a large building. Everything in that building has to either work for a good century or so, or have a suitable number of replacements. You might be able to grow some food to supplement pre-packed supplies. That in itself would require a fair bit of space and some soil supplements to keep it fertile.
No matter what happens you will not be rescued. So you have to be able to deal with planned and likely unplanned events. For example at something like 0.1 C hitting anything large than a grain of sand is going to poke a huge crater in the nose of the spacecraft. So there’d need to be radar of some sort to detect any objects at long distance so there’s time to turn enough to avoid them. That burns up irreplaceable manoeuvring fuel.
And don’t think that interstellar space is completely empty, there is likely to be comet heads, asteroids, etc.

So no, I very much doubt that we’re ever going to get to another star system without either FTL or some kind of very high C drive. The problems are colossal.

Reply Quote View full thread