Woodie said:
Spiny Norman said:
Pauline Hanson under fire for ‘bigoted’ call to remove children with disabilities from mainstream classroomsDisability advocates and politicians have slammed One Nation senator Pauline Hanson’s call for children with autism and disabilities to be removed from mainstream classrooms, saying the “hurtful” idea would amount to “segregation”.
The Queensland senator made the suggestion during debate on the Federal Government’s school funding legislation, saying children with disabilities were putting a strain on teachers and schools and should be educated separately.
“These kids have a right to an education, by all means, but, if there are a number of them, these children should go into a special classroom and be looked after and given that special attention,” she said.
“Most of the time the teacher spends so much time on them they forget about the child who is straining at the bit and wants to go ahead in leaps and bounds in their education.
“That child is held back by those others, because the teachers spend time with them.
“I am not denying them. If it were one of my children I would love all the time given to them to give them those opportunities. But it is about the loss for our other kids.
“I think that we have more autistic children, yet we are not providing the special classrooms or the schools for these autistic children.
What say Ms Angel?
There’s hundreds of studies about autistic children in mainstream education. Almost all of them (according to meta studies of said literature) recommend the following:
- teacher training to recognise different characteristics of autism as it presents differently in everyone, including siblings
- specialised support systems, reasonable adjustments, flexible learning
- widespread adoption of practices such as UDL and other inclusion practices
- explicit teaching of social and other life skills
- Support in the form of TAs and wellbeing staff
- autistic and ADHD children in mainstream typically are better at life skills like getting a job than children who are not in mainstream (obviously there’s a bias because to be in a special school, the child is already requiring a high level of support which means sometimes they cannot find suitable employment or other opportunities); but look at Temple Grandin who was recommended to be institutionalised. Her mother was told Temple was “low functioning” (as was the terminology back then) and would likely never communicate. Temple is an expert in her field and holds several degrees, including a PhD.
However, there are an increasing number of specialised schools for children with cognitive differences, which seems to be what she’s referring to, as opposed to say, cerebral palsy kids. These special schools have smaller class numbers and more support staff. There’s a school I applied for when I first qualified as a TA which has a class size of fifteen kids to one teacher and two TAs per class (I’m so glad I didn’t get the job, I lacked the knowledge and experience I have now). These special schools have limitations: teacher shortage, high staff turnover (it’s a challenging gig both physcially and mentally), limited class sizes so kids who need it often are on a waiting list.
Last but certainly not least: autism is a spectrum. With a diagnosis of autism, kids are given a level of support: 1 meaning low support, to 3 meaning high support (the kid I’m currently supporting, pseudonym Hugo, is level 3). I’m going to make the assumption that Pauline Hanson means level 3 kids. While segregation might be fine for some kids, it won’t work for others, but importantly, it also teaches typically-developing children that people different to them are somehow less than. There’s a wealth of studies proving bullying is more likely to occur to autistic children, who will then grow up to have mental health issues. Autistic adults have between 33%-66% higher rate of suicidal ideation than non-autistic adults. Stigmatisation of neurodivergent people of all ages is a dangerous thing. Children need to be around autistic kids to promote tolerance, acceptance, and inclusion.
Unless you’ve got 1:1 support for every autistic child, other kids are going to fly under the radar regardless of whether the classroom is full of autistic kids or a mix of neurodivergent and neurotypical.